Can we talk openly about sexual abuse? What The Keepers sparked in me.

I watched The Keepers on Netflix. It brought up a lot of memories, emotions (sadness, anger), and questions. Abuse of any kind is awful. Sexual abuse against children is awful. Sexual abuse against children at the hands of those they trust, like teachers, is awful. For some reason, for me, sexual abuse against children at the hands of religious leaders is even worse. Not only are they people we trust, but we see them as God’s own presence amongst us. We see religious leaders as Jesus incarnate and almost as demi-gods. And they know it. I have spoken with many religious leaders throughout my life, and many are very proud to be ‘God’s instruments on Earth’. Many think they are above reproach and are so proud of their humility. Even the “good” ones sometimes disappoint with their own accounts of being so near to God. I have also heard many religious leaders say, “I would never do that!” when another religious leader “falls”. But the Bible warns: So, if you think you are standing firm, be careful that you don’t fall! 1 Corinthians 10:12

I was taught that religious leaders are to be respected and obeyed. I thank God that throughout most of my life the leaders I encountered were kind, wise, and God-fearing. I thank God that my own parents have been great examples of God and service. But I am also aware of many who are not. Every abuse that I heard on The Keepers was unbelievable, gut-wrenching, and devastatingly real. Abuse from a trusted, loved, and respected adult is unconceivable. Abuse at the hands of God’s chosen, God’s representatives, God’s anointed, is almost unbearable. If you are a survivor, like me, you understand. Because for me, it did not turn me away from God. I have turned out alright. I have remained in leadership in the Church. I still have faith in “the call” of people who go into ordained ministry. And because even though I carry the scars deep inside, I still can help others in similar situations and give them hope. For others, that sort of abuse was unbearable.

I have heard so many jokes about sexual abuse by teachers or priests, usually made by teachers or priests. “He’s sweating like a pedophile at a Boys Scouts meeting!” “She obviously couldn’t get anyone else to sleep with her!” “Hey, he got lucky, and then got caught!” Some people say that high school girls want sex and tempt their male teachers or religious leaders. I have heard survivors say those ridiculous things. Why? I wonder if it is because they want to take back their power. I wonder if it is because they want to say that their abuse happened by their own choice, not because someone took their innocence or virginity by force. But the reality is clear. Adults in positions of power or influence are the people who are supposed to keep the children safe. Adults in positions of power or influence are supposed to care, nurture, educate, and love the children near them. Adults in position of power or influence have a responsibility not only to steer away from questionable situations (alone with a child, alone with a child with the door closed, alone with a child waiting for a parent to come pick them up, etc.), but stand up against stupid jokes, or people who may be involved in abuse.

But we are afraid. I have heard people say – I can’t stand up for that student because I am not their teacher. I can’t say anything because I may be wrong. I don’t want people to hate me. Recently, a 50 year old married self-professed “Jesus freak/child of The King, husband, father, grandfather, high-school teacher, clinician, drummer, audio tech, jeep owner, singer/songwriter, warrior-poet” kidnapped his 15 year old student for over a month. I kept up with this manhunt and read that students had seen them kissing on the lips (by the way, why would any teacher kiss a student?) and had confronted him. He said they were very close because she was his “best friend”! I also read comments about another recent teacher-student sexual “relationship” (why do we call it that instead of what it really is – abuse!) written by other students at the school – they said they knew about the situation but didn’t want to say anything. Why? I understand that maybe I as a 14 year old might have a total crush on a 25 or 30 or 40 year old teacher, but for my teacher to then engage in sexual behavior with me is NOT love! It is abuse! Why? Because the adult, especially a teacher or religious leader, has promised to protect the child.

I wish there were spaces where we could talk about abuse. I wish we had safe spaces where we could come to ask questions and share experiences and emotions, however painful they may be, with people who want to help and not judge. I wish sex (in all its forms, including abuse) were not so taboo in the Church. It is almost incredible to me that there are many people who would rather keep Mary a virgin than think she ever had a sexual relationship with her husband and had other children. It is no wonder many teens, myself included, never know who to honestly speak with about sex. I wish we could have honest and open conversations about sex, not about remaining a virgin till marriage, not about not masturbating, not about antiquated or judgmental stigmas about sex, but honest, uncomfortable, maybe even giggle-inducing conversations. I have had them with my son and nephew and nieces and other youths who have been very close to me and I am certain they have felt uncomfortable at times. I would rather they feel uncomfortable with me, a loving, intelligent, educated, Christian adult, than get misguided or outright wrong information from others.

This is a very important subject for me. As a survivor, I feel it is my duty to report and to confront. I also know that other victims/survivors do not feel this way. I know that there are some who prefer anonymity. I know there are others who prefer to pretend it didn’t happen. I also know that some of us remember after the fact, having suppressed the memory. I have heard and read it was my body’s way of protecting me. When I remembered the abuse that happened to me at the seminary in Guatemala, where my dad went to school to be an evangelical pastor when I was between 5-9, I was already living in the US. It just cascaded into my mind. I could smell and see and hear and taste and almost touch the abuse. It was awful. Some years passed, and I was able to confront my abuser by phone (he called our house – but that’s another story). Before I picked up the phone, I knew. It was odd. I was trembling. “Hello?” “¡Sandrita!” “Yo sé. I know” “No te hice nada de eso. I didn’t do any of that to you.” I hadn’t mentioned anything except those two words: “I know.” For all those years before I was able to confront him on the phone I wondered – are my memories fake? Am I crazy? Did it really happen? I am very grateful to God that I had the opportunity to confront my abuser and that he finally confirmed that it was true. I told him never to call my house again, and if he ever did that I would go to the police, because the statute of limitations hadn’t expired. I mentioned his wife and children (his son was very close to me during that time) and said – “would you have liked to know that your daughter was also being abused at the age you did it to me?” He was beside himself. Never heard of or from him again.

You may have a similar situation. You may hate your abuser. I told mine – I hope God forgives you because I never will. Yet when I hung up, I was delivered from hate or remorse or guilt. Yeah, y’all know we often blame the victim and many of us believe we could have stopped it – why didn’t I scream? Why didn’t I bite? Why didn’t I say anything to my parents? Before that day, I couldn’t talk about it, and the few times I did it was with tears. But now I can share my story of survival with anyone who needs to be comforted. There can be life, abundant life, after abuse, even though every story is different. I am very lucky that I was not killed or suffered depression or any other traumas common among victims. Although I may not have a husband I don’t think it’s because of the abuse. In fact, I often say I can blame my decisions on others or I can take responsibility for them. I choose to take responsibility for my actions and decisions. I will not give such a tiny, evil “man of God” power over my life. The abuse remains with me; it is part of me…but it does not come close to defining me.


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Fourth Sunday, Fourth Church: Holy Cross, Sugar Land, TX

This is why people don't or can't or won't speak up

A little story about a job I lost years ago and Reading the Bible Chronologically in 2018 Day 8 Job 17-20