This is why people don't or can't or won't speak up
Several years ago, I became a whistle blower in tec. Some of you know about it. I was forced to talk to the person I had gone to several times before I went to their supervisor who promised
anonymity and protection. She told me I could trust her. She told me nobody would know it was me. I was so scared and nervous. It had to be done. I'm glad I did it. I am glad because some things changed in tec. But things changed for me too. I was forced to have a meeting with the person and their supervisor. The supervisor was supposed to protect me. And she didn't. Because the person was not mature enough to take responsibility, he took his frustration out on me and I became persona non grata since then. It was awful. The ministries I loved and some that I had started or was there from the beginning were now taken from me and I was not invited and not welcome to attend. People stopped talking to me and started gossiping about me to others - including people who hired me for singing and speaking and writing engagements. And, I lost a lot of money and jobs and, unfortunately, many people who also are immature stopped talking to me without giving me a chance.
At General Convention, several racist things happened that I decided to speak out on. Some are on facebook. And, because people are immature and some white people cannot take being called out when they think their tec jobs are much more important than being anti-racist, inclusive, diverse, compassionate they will lie and gossip and block and say things like – why are you listening to HER?? She is the angry one. She is always calling anything white people do racist. She is the aggressive one who attacks white people. She hates white people. And then, of course, I am back to being the cancelled one. Not them. Me.
So, because I know and many of us know that we are the ones who pay for speaking out, we don’t feel like speaking out or showing up or standing up or crying out any more. I wish you understood what it feels like to see and know racism. To hear someone yelling “IT’S THE ORANGE BUTTON!!” over and over at an elder who does not speak English and who has never been out of their country and who can barely walk and is tiny and who is looking at the angry white tall male flight attendant with inquisitive eyes after she has just been allowed to go to the restroom even though she asked over and over before the plane left the airport and doesn’t know how to flush and he yells louder and louder as though she didn’t understand “orange button” because she couldn’t hear it and not because those sounds mean nothing to her. I wanted to get out of my seat and scream at the man and then enter the tiny restroom and flush the toilet for her. But I was exhausted and scared. The tall man had already made a face at me when I told him – “it’s obviously an emergency, can’t she go?” as he kept repeating “you can’t go to the restroom now; you must sit!” and buckled her in as she insisted she needed to go. She said “go” so many times. I am so grateful the Black flight attendant was so patient and sweet as she pointed to the button and almost went inside the restroom with her even as the man kept yelling ORANGE!!! BTW the flush button is blue with a thin red light around it.
I wish you could feel what I felt when I saw her praising God with her arms raised as we landed but her voice was silent; I started raising my hands with her and she smiled. But did not use her voice any more. Because she wasn’t heard. But God heard. I wish you would have felt what I did when she, as we were getting off the plane, asked to use the restroom again and wanted water but the tall white man said, “No!” loudly as the other flight attendant sweetly but firmly led her to her wheelchair. The two wheelchairs were there and I am so glad I was there because even though the white man behind me, the white male pilot and the white tall male flight attendant I did not allow anyone to pass them. Even as they mocked them with “Geez!” and laughter and frustrated faces and even as one older white man said, “I wish they would move them to the side!” It took probably three minutes for them to be seated on their wheelchairs. But with the last audible mock I couldn’t stay quiet anymore and I turned to the three white men and said, “They are our elders. Let them get settled! What is the big deal?!” “I wish they would move them so we could go,” said the man behind me who was Jewish and was talking about God with another Jewish man behind me the whole flight. I turned and looked at him and asked, “would you feel the same if that was you? We will hopefully get to that age and we may need people to wait for us. How would you feel if you heard people say – move him!” The three men looked at me like I was over reacting. I am used to those looks. And, I don’t care. I am used to them because I see them all the time in tec. All. The. Time.
I wish you could feel what I feel when a white person who reads your book and “admires” you hears you speak and suddenly the smile fades because they find you too tough, too aggressive, too angry. I always want to give white people or people who are phobic against LGBTQIA2S+ a trigger warning before I speak or when they say they want to follow me on socials after they hear me sing. I don’t sound like my songs when I speak or write. I need to change that and write differently rather than only about my love for Jesus.
I wish you could feel what I feel when a white woman cries because I have “harmed” her with truth and everyone, including people of the global majority go to her aid. I don’t feel bad nor does it hurt that she is crying as a way to derail the conversation or to recenter it to her needs but I do feel awful seeing how she is still seen as the most valuable, the most fragile, the one to help. I wish you could feel my heart race like I did when, in a multicultural bilingual setting a woman who did not speak or understand English was put in a circle with five other people. One of them was a pastor and a bilingual person and another was kind of bilingual. She asked if she could be added to a group with more Spanish speakers and was told no because we were there to learn from others. She sat there. Scared. Unable to understand, unable to speak, unable to move. She was asked after three others spoke, “did you understand?” She said, “no, sólo entendí algo de hermano, hermana.” She was skipped and later it was the bilingual pastor’s turn. He speaks with a Portuguese accent in both English and Spanish. He spoke for a long time in English and then said, “let me summarize for her” and said one line in Spanish. I wanted to run to her and say, “ahora tú di lo que quieras en español y nadie va a interpretarlo.” But I wanted to believe that the organizers would speak up. That this might be a teachable moment. But it wasn’t. While I was witnessing this, a white woman spoke in my group. My group was 5 gente Latina where one person did not speak English and one person spoke a little English, the leader is bilingual, a person who spoke very little Spanish and me. Everything was translated for the one person who didn’t speak English. She was the focus. When she started speaking she said she was going to try her Spanish. All of us were supportive. After she tried a bit she then spoke in English and the leader asked if I wanted to interpret and I said, “no!” After everyone left, it was me, the leader, the white woman and her husband. I said that I was upset because of what had happened. I said, why would I want to interpret when my sister in the other table didn’t have an interpreter? The white woman had said in her comments that she only had white friends, white neighbors, white church friends, white work peers. And she cried when she mentioned the immigration reform (I think that’s what it was). We spoke about white women tears. We spoke about how everyone worries about white women but the dark Brown Latina was left to fend for herself. I was angry and I apologized to my Latina sibling the next day when I saw her again because she left after the experience. She told me how awful she felt. And said that always happens to her.
It is so hard to speak up. It costs us so much. It is exhausting. It is not fun. It brings repercussions. I get called into the “principal’s” office so much it is laughable – in jobs, in tec, in life. I have also noticed how easy it is for people to let me know what they think about me. They want to tell me how angry I am. People in high rankings in tec have asked me “why are you always so angry?” in various ways. Remember that tec’s PB elect said “let’s use our anger at injustice instead of turning it inward” in his address to tec when he was elected. Anger is a trigger word. It is what PGM particularly women are often accused of.
It is so easy for people to tell me – if you would say your message differently, softly, carefully people would listen. I don’t agree. People listen. People have changed. People scramble to look for other PGM or other music that is not white-centric, when I speak up. I know this. I have seen it. However, they are not going to ever give me credit. Ever. I am not going to change because it makes white people uncomfortable or PGM who want to stay close with whiteness uncomfortable. I am always available to dialogue. I love to have discussions and conversations. I won’t bow down to whiteness. I’ve done that for too long.
One note that comes up often – “Sandra,” I am told, “you shouldn’t use social media to make your points. You should not use social media to communicate with others. You shouldn’t use social media to call out racism.” And on and on. I write, I email, I call before posting on social media. I go on social media when nobody responds – which is often. They rather ignore me than start a conversation with me. People in positions of power and influence in tec don’t seem to do well with confrontation or truth-telling. Now, if racism is on social media, I am going to use the original posts and call it out, of course. I am not going to go to the person to ask – hey, diocese of tec, did you mean to be racist by posting a bishop slate with five cis het white men? Or did you mean to be diverse and inclusive? Nah, I’m just gonna ask everyone’s opinion of the very public slate.
Anyways… this is why it sucks to speak up. But I won’t, can’t and don’t stop.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteSiento profundamente el dolor que has experimentado y el silencio que te rodea. Como sacerdote, quiero recordarte que Dios te escucha y te acompaña en tu lucha por la justicia. No estás sola o sola en este camino.
ReplyDeleteEn la Biblia, el Señor nos llama a ser defensores ya defensores: "Aprended a hacer el bien; buscad la justicia, corregid al opresor, defendido al huérfano, abogad por la viuda" (Isaías 1:17). Tus esfuerzos por alzar la voz reflejan el corazón de Cristo, quien siempre estuvo del lado de los marginados.
Jesús mismo sufrió injusticias, pero no se rindió. Él nos dice: "Bienaventurados los que sufren persecución por causa de la justicia, porque de ellos es el reino de los cielos" (Mateo 5:10). Esto nos recuerda que tu valentía y esfuerzo tienen un propósito mayor en el plan de Dios, y que tus acciones resonarán en la eternidad.
Sigue denunciando, sabiendo que Dios es un Dios de justicia: "El Señor es refugio de los oprimidos, su baluarte en momentos de angustia" (Salmos 9:9). Él es tu fuerza y tu protector.
Nunca subestimes el poder de tu voz. Dios te ha llamado a ser luz en medio de las tinieblas ya proclamar su amor y justicia en un mundo que a menudo no escucha. Mantén la valentía, sigue defendiendo a los vulnerables y recuerda siempre que "el que persevera hasta el fin, ése será salvo" (Mateo 24:13).