I Remain. Will You?
On discomfort, courage and refusing silence in a white-supremacist church — a testimony of voice, vulnerability and persistence in the face of policing and erasure, exposing the double standard of who gets heard, who gets silenced and why truth still must be spoken, especially in a church that praises my songs but not my voice.
I am always uncomfortable when I speak up. If I only spoke when I felt discomfort, I would never stop talking. I speak up when I see injustice and then I persist, even though it costs me. I remain.
Even in church services in the Episcopal Church, I feel that discomfort, but I stay. I can pray and sing, though I cannot sit still. You know I am going to sing loudly and shout amen if I love a sermon or a reading. That is how I remain present even when it hurts.
The discomfort I carry in worship done in English is not mine alone. It is a reflection of what People of the Global Majority live daily. Our voices are policed, our presence questioned, our truth unwelcome. And we see this pattern magnified in public.
Remember what just happened to Taylor Townsend? Instead of being asked how she felt when she was insulted and demeaned, she was asked how she forgave, how she understood, why she extended grace. Why was the responsibility placed on her, a Black woman, instead of on the person who harmed her? Why wasn’t she asked how she was doing, if she was giving herself space and gentleness or what people could do for her. That is racism at work.
Or look at Charlie Kirk’s murder. People of the Global Majority are expected to mourn, to stay silent, to not speak ill of the dead. Yet many of us are not feeling it. Many don’t agree. I do not think he should have been murdered but I also do not think he was a compassionate follower of Jesus doing Jesus’ work on earth. His ideology was white supremacist, his words demeaned People of the Global Majority, especially Black women. And still, in death, he is being called a martyr. Christians across the globe proclaim his death noble and tragic, as if he carried a cross. Meanwhile I cannot understand how so many others killed daily for being queer, trans, disabled, outspoken, poor or for simply existing as People of the Global Majority are not canonized or lifted up in the same way.
The double standard is glaring. The hypocrisy is everywhere — whose deaths are honored, whose voices are dismissed, whose actions are excused. I cannot control how the world canonizes or erases, but I can control my own integrity. So when someone tells me I’ve harmed them, I don’t hide behind excuses, I do not deflect, I don’t dismiss it or hide. I take responsibility and I apologize. I don’t say “I’m sorry you felt…” or “I’m sorry if…” or “sorry the impact was different than my intent” (if you know me, you know how much that makes me uncomfortable lol. I don’t dilute an apology with conditions. I say plainly: “Please forgive me for ___.” Or “I am really sorry for ___.” Forgiveness is free and humility costs me nothing. That is how I try to live because my parents always apologized without making excuses. They know the power of an apology and forgiveness is freedom.
Sadly, the same grace I extend is not returned. Instead, I am constantly policed. People roll their eyes, sigh, make faces, whisper behind my back or tell me to “shut up.” And rarely — so rarely — does anyone say, “Thank you for naming that. Thank you for your courage.”
I feel that when my truth is too much for them, they deflect. Instead of engaging my heart or my values, they latch onto what feels safe to comment on — my singing voice, my earrings, my style. And I love being seen that way. But what about my values? What about my morality, my integrity, my heart? Why is it so easy to talk about my outfits but so hard to acknowledge my passion for justice? Why is it easier to critique my tone than to grapple with the truths I’m naming?
Discomfort is not harm. Discomfort is what you feel when truth shakes your illusions. Harm is what happens when systems keep people marginalized, voiceless or dead.
When I name injustices: like the Episcopal Church’s consistent failures with including Spanish [in print and with interpretation] in all church-wide events and with translation and interpretation after decades of “trying” - that is not a personal attack. It is not harm. It is discomfort. It is a mirror being held up.
But whiteness and white-centricity and longing to being adjacent to whiteness {because for so long it has meant being in positions of power and influence} flip the script. My words are labeled “harmful” while the actual harm of silencing, dismissing and excluding is ignored.
Why do many people of the global minority think they have the right to say how they feel? Why are they raised to believe their voices and thoughts — even the negative ones — are valuable, must be spoken, must be respected? It is because from birth, the system has taught them that their voices matter, that their feelings are universal, that their perspectives are the standard. Their anger gets reframed as passion. Their cruelty is excused as honesty. They inherit a culture that insists their words deserve an audience. Their “kindness” or “goodness” or “being proper” is applauded and held as how everyone should act. However, those values are measured differently for People of the Global Majority. The United States systems value passive aggressiveness and micro-aggressions towards any group that has been marginalized and punishes directness from People of the Global Majority or anyone who should be “quiet.”
Meanwhile, People of the Global Majority are taught the opposite by these systems. We are taught that our voices are dangerous, our feelings excessive, our perspectives biased. We learn that every word we speak must be measured because the consequences can be devastating. Our voices are policed as angry, scary, aggressive, inappropriate. We are told to soften, to wait, to whisper. And when we do speak, the focus is not on what we said but how we said it.
This is the architecture of white supremacy: global minority voices are assumed to be inherently valuable, even when they are false or harmful. People of the Global Majority are assumed to be disruptive or threatening, even when we are telling the truth.
Tone policing is one of the sharpest tools of white supremacy. Instead of reckoning with injustice, it shifts the focus to whether I sounded “sweet” enough, “calm” enough, “gentle” enough. I’ve been told I should whisper. I’ve been told I should find a nicer way to say things. And sometimes I joke: maybe I should just sing all my critiques. Because apparently the only time my voice is welcome is when it entertains, not when it disrupts.
When I raise concerns, I am speaking about systems, not individuals. If I had an issue with a specific person, I would go directly to them. If you know me, you know it is true and how I have been for many years – children and young people taught me that. I value my learnings from children and youth as a teacher and mentor because they may say things that hurt, but they usually come from a place of love and truth, not malice.
So when people twist my words into “personal attacks,” it says more about them than about me. I wish I could remember that because it is very painful to be thought of as an attacker, a harmer, a mean spirited, a rude, a person who only criticizes and on and on. The truth is that whiteness cannot tolerate being confronted. I have experienced that people of the global minority and men lash out, not because I am wrong, but because I refuse to stay silent.
All of this policing — of tone, of presence, of voice — serves one purpose: to maintain power where it has always lived. The Episcopal Church loves to say it values justice, inclusion and diversity. But when a Person of the Global Majority names obvious, fixable injustices — like translation failures, like tokenizing hires, like including Spanish in all TEC posts and publishes, like hiring people who speak other languages and are multiracial to jobs historically linked with people of the global minority, like adding cultural relevance, like including various voices in planning and not waiting for the last minute, like exclusion baked into daily operations — the response is not gratitude. It is resistance. It is gossip. It is marginalizing. It is blocking jobs and elections and appointments. It is erasing.
And yet — I know my courage has not been in vain. People have told me they found courage in their own lives because they saw mine. Recently, someone told me they see me as fearless, and they want to be a little more like that every day. Those words are balm for my soul. They are cool water from Jesus, poured out exactly when I am about to give up, parched.
I am exhausted. Exhausted of being told to soften, to forgive, to reconcile, to be filled with grace. Exhausted of being attacked not for what I say, but for daring to say anything at all. Exhausted of seeing my voice praised when it entertains but punished when it disrupts.
But I will not be silent. Because discomfort is not harm. And because truth deserves a voice even when it shakes the room. And y’all know I can shake a room with my songs & dance moves. I wonder if my voice will ever be respected for telling the uncomfortable truth even when others disagree. I thought things might change after a master’s degree, then after a doctorate, then after becoming Dean. But I remain appreciated for the songs I sing — especially in Spanish — not for the research, experience, education and wisdom I bring into this beloved church of mine that proclaims she wants to follow Jesus and turn tables and go against empire. But that can only be done with courage, discomfort, disagreement and conversations — not with policing, not with worrying about tone, not with worrying about protecting feelings. I AM VERY SENSITIVE!!! Yet I remain, even when all of my fucking feelings have been hurt. Will you?
Comments
Post a Comment